Tuesday 14 August 2012

Big Finish review: the Key 2 Time trilogy


Featuring:
117 The Judgement Of Iskaar
118 The Destroyer Of Delights
119 The Chaos Pool

Main range release 117 The Judgement Of Iskaar (Simon Guerrier)
Released January 2009

This release reintroduces the Key to Time to the Doctor Who universe. First appearing in season 16, the quest to recover and assemble its six segments joined together the Fourth Doctor, Romana and K9. At the conclusion of this search, the Doctor scattered the segments again because the alternative was to give it to the Black Guardian.
Now in his Fifth incarnation, the Doctor finds himself on a rainy planet, summoned by a newly born human tracer whom he names Amy. She informs him that he will help her relocate the segments because they are destroying the universe. This audio shows the Doctor and Amy locating three out of the six segments, on Chaos, Mars and Safeplace. It also introduces Amy’s ‘twin’, if you like, Zara. To keep balance, the Grace (the Key’s creators) made Amy and Zara to collect three segments each. But Zara wants all of them.
I like how Amy and Zara are equal and opposite in a way. Both are recently created and have the means to locate and store the segments. But their behaviour is opposite. Zara’s experiences before the events of this audio have made her opportunistic and selfish, shown in how she leaves partner in crime Zinc (no, I am not kidding) to die at the hands of the Ice Warriors. By contrast, Amy shows compassion, having moulded herself on the Doctor. This connection will echo in later stories featuring the characters.

I will admit that the story can get confusing. We don’t want to see the Doctor at the Genesis of the Ice Warriors, or how he was involved. When the action moves to Safeplace, the conflict between the Valdigians and the Ice Warriors is puzzling. I would just sonic cannon the castle to bits or damage the foundations so the castle collapsed.

Good effort, but three segments in one story can seem much. On the bright side, the next two audios can focus on one segment apiece. Oh, that cliffhanger….

Main range release 118 The Destroyer Of Delights (Jonathan Clements)
Released February 2009

If the last story looked at the range of appearances each segment could take, this one shows the Guardians, who played a small part in the original Key to Time.

The last story ended with the Doctor and Amy stuck on a ship falling into a sun, separated from the Tardis and faced with the Black Guardian (voiced by David Troughton!). The opening scene establishes how the next segment (note how it is never referred to as the fifth segment, correct me if I’m wrong) is nowhere is space and time. Both guardians have been searching for millennia and found zip, nada nothing. So the Doctor proposes something not unfamiliar to the guardian: randomosity (I paraphrased). So the Doctor ends up in the desert and Amy in a palace, both in 9th century Sudan.

This audio highlights Amy’s reliance on others to determine her behaviour. She has had only the Doctor to learn from, and has no other experience. Needless to say, he inexperience and naivety drive Nisrin up the wall (figuratively, not literally, because that would be a blatant anachronism) especially when it comes to Prince Omar. This confusion goes two ways, as listeners will find out.

There is an element of who’s who, if you have a keen ear, or have read the cast list for this and the next story. Try to identify the Cassim or the Caliphate before the Doctor can. The alien in the story does not over stay or impose on other characters. In fact, many elements of this story stem from, and in the DW universe will inspire, Arabian Nights, as writer Jonathan Clements mentions is the bonus features. Aladdin will seem the most obvious, what with the treasure cave and all.

One final thing, the nature of this segment is very creative. It highlights a problem found with Eternals, in that a person has to come up with an idea for the Eternal to have it. The idea that the segment comes into being through the Black Guardian’s actions towards finding it is clever. This kind of twist makes the story a very good one, one that surpasses Judgement.

Main range release 119 The Chaos Pool (Peter Anghelides)
Released March 2009

Acting as the trilogy’s finale, there is naturally a lot at stake. The Teuthoidians are arriving from the dawn of time to face the Atrians (is that right?) who come from the end of time above the planet Chaos, location of the fabled Chaos Pool. Members of the Atrios fleet include Professor Lydel (a guess who character), Princess Astra and a certain human tracer called Zara…

It is here that the Doctor and Amy come in, become separated from the TARDIS (as usual) and get underway with the search for the sixth segment of the Key. After some identity confusion, the search for the Chaos Pool is underway..

I like how Zara has developed. As she has experienced the universe, she becomes her own person, as opposed to an agent of The Grace. Zara has learned to love, and this is very different to the antagonistic behaviour she exhibited back in Judgement. She is encouraged to make her own choices, not to do as others ask of her.

Concerning the nature of the sixth segment, this story links back to the original Key to Time finale, the Armageddon Factor in that the segment is a person. Also harking back to that story is sixth member of the sixth something being crucial the story. In this case the captain of the Atrios fleet, Pargrave (Zara’s crush) is the sixth son of his family’s sixth generation. Funny how his path led to the sixth segment!

Lalla Ward does double duty and plays both Astra, who has aged curiously, and Romana. (Another Armageddon link!) This allows for an interesting turn in regard to who turns into a segment. It seems that being restored to a human segment caused Astra to draw on the life energy of those around her ie the Atrians. This gave her a sort of immortality at the cost her people. To save them, she allowed herself to be the home of the sixth segments essence, sparing Romana. What a surprise!

Upon the conclusion of this tale, Amy is written out so the Doctor can return to Peri. I found Amy an interesting companion. She demonstrated just how the world around us and the people we meet influence us. Given that she was created for the purpose of the Doctor having a new companion (reflecting Romana’s original recruitment perhaps?) Amy had no further use. She has been quite good in the Graceless series, so I recommend giving that a listen.


Did you enjoy this review? if so, please comment on any releases or trilogies that you want me to listen to.

No comments:

Post a Comment